The Federal High Court sitting in Abuja, Federal Capital Territory (FCT), has ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to publish the name of Dr Gabriel Suswam as the duly nominated All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for the 2027 Benue North-East Senatorial District (Zone A) election.
Dr. Suswam had approached the court to challenge his alleged unlawful substitution after emerging victorious in the APC senatorial primary election. Although the primary election committee declared him the winner, the name of the incumbent senator, Emmanuel Udende, appeared on INEC’s list of candidates.
Last month, the case took an unexpected turn when the court directed the parties to address it on the implications of the Supreme Court’s September 24, 2026, decision in INEC v. Zenith Labour Party, which restored Sections 77 and 84(2) of the Electoral Act after they had earlier been struck out by the Court of Appeal.
INEC had earlier informed the court that its records showed Suswam won the primary election, having polled the highest number of valid votes.
In their final addresses, both parties urged the court to rule in their favour, seeking the dismissal of the opposing claims and the grant of their respective reliefs.
The matter was initially slated for judgment on December 21. However, in a dramatic turn of events, Justice Inyang Ekwo delivered judgment on Wednesday, November 18, ruling that the evidence presented by Suswam was corroborated by INEC’s report.
The court held that neither the APC nor Senator Udende had challenged INEC’s report and that it had no contrary report to rely on. It also rejected Exhibit Udende 1, describing its origin as dubious.
The judgment followed the dismissal of two preliminary objections filed by Senator Udende and the APC challenging the competence of Suswam’s suit.
Reacting to the judgment, a legal practitioner, Jirgba Terfa Jirgba, Esq, described Dr. Suswam’s case as compelling, both in fact and law, expressing full agreement with the court’s decision.
Jirgba, Esq. faulted the defences presented by Sen Udende and the APC, particularly the argument that Sen Udende mistook Comr Austin Agada for the recognised party chairman and consequently participated in primaries conducted under Agada’s authority.
He questioned whether Agada was even a member of the committee officially constituted to conduct the primary election, while also raising concerns over what he described as inconsistencies in the presentation and attribution of votes between Suswam and Agada.
According to the lawyer, the court was unequivocal in its orders, restraining Udende from parading himself as the APC senatorial candidate for Benue North-East and directing the party to immediately forward Suswam’s name to INEC as its duly recognised candidate.
On the possibility of a stay of execution, Jirgba argued that the judgment contained declaratory reliefs, which are generally not amenable to a stay of execution under established legal principles.
He, however, acknowledged Sen Udende’s constitutional right to appeal, stressing that the mere filing of an appeal does not automatically suspend the effect of the judgment.
“In my considered legal opinion, Suswam has secured a significant victory, both politically and judicially. The law must take its course, and the APC should comply with the court’s orders without unnecessary delay,” he said.
Meanwhile, Senator Udende has rejected the judgment and indicated his intention to challenge it at the Court of Appeal.
One of his lawyers, who spoke to The New Times on condition of anonymity, confirmed the planned appeal, saying: “Clearly, the judgment will be appealed.”


